Bc.7 - The Wallet & CPL fallback options

Aiming at high availability, an alternative to use NIM must be available for every user always. This becomes real only when Bc.1 to Bc.6 are in place, the web version exists (Ba.4) and Theme Bf (Ledger) is resolved.

1 Like

Thanks for opening this up. A question from the builder side.

Quite a few community tools don’t hold keys themselves and sign through the Hub (hub.nimiq.com) instead: browser extensions, websites with a Nimiq checkout, and the desktop path of Mini Apps that also run outside Nimiq Pay. My NimSide extension and the desktop flow of NimBooks both work this way, so keys stay in the Keyguard.

The roadmap covers fallbacks for the Wallet and CPL, but I couldn’t find the Hub mentioned. When the Wallet is wound down (Bg.4), will the Hub stay available to third-party sites and extensions? If it is going to be replaced, for example by the web version of Nimiq Pay (Ba.4), will websites get a comparable way to request a payment or a signature?

Knowing this early would help builders avoid building on something that is about to change.

Nimiq Wallet should be kept. Last major wallet update was the staking support and additional security backup. It is more polished than old Nimiq Safe if it becomes legacy app alternative to Nimiq Pay. It runs as a browser node too.

Thanks @frvfrvr the main plan is to have all features of the wallet available in Nimiq Pay. This would include staking, browser node and also making it as polished as the wallet. At that point instead of deciding if the wallet is kept or sunset, it would actually be feasible to merge those in some way.

So the wallet becomes the web app equivalent of Nimiq Pay and instead of having two different products we actually have one single product, with same features, that can be accessed from both mobile app store and regular web browser.

I hope that helps explains this section. Let me know what you think.

Question from user Wool on Telegram:

Thanks, so one of the things in favour of browser-based was not being totally dependent on app stores - so does the Nimiq Pay roadmap retain this strength of the browser-based wallet?

Answer:

Yes. Nimiq Pay as a web app is planned as well. So you can install it and use it on your phone. Or also use it on its web app form.

The result is that some features would only be available on the mobile app version (biometrics for example) but the core functionality would always be available, on web app or on mobile app.

Question from user Wool in Telegram:

Given that things are only as strong as the weakest link, does (web native) miniapps which live within an app store-dependent Nimiq Pay app deliver censorship-resistance

Answer:

Nimiq Pay is also planned to get a web app version (think of Nimiq Pay being accessed like the wallet). And then Mini Apps would be accessed from this web app version.

You can also see it as Mini Apps being supported by the wallet.

The point is to bring feature parity to both Nimiq Pay and the Wallet so instead of having two disconnected products we have one single product with the same features that can be accessed from within Mobile Stores, and Web Browser.

Question from user Andrjoo on Telegram:

These are great questions. Personally, the centralization of the mini app and also the slowness makes me skeptical of using it. It takes 30 seconds just to load my balance, which is an excruciating amount of time when I’m trying to pay. I don’t think that most US residence would find this practical.

I also I’m not a fan of relying on App downloads. I love the idea of being able to access my wallet and apps from any browser in the world.

Answer:

Thanks. That’s actually very good feedback. We should find a way to make mini apps load faster to make it more usable.

Regarding the comment on being able to access Mini apps from everywhere and not relying on App Stores or Mobile support, I clarified that the plan is to also have Mini App support in a web version of Nimiq Pay (like the wallet). This is part of this milestone in the roadmap: Ba.4 - Evaluate web and desktop versions of Nimiq Pay

Comment from user wool on Telegram.

Thanks for sharing your hands-on experience and sentiments!

It could be that in some ways the highly decentralised browser-based web wallet is peerless, yet at the same time going nowhere in terms of adoption.

Therefore, right now, the team urgently needs to pivot to something that will gain adoption in the short to medium term.

However, maybe it could be good if the team keeps the door open for the legacy technology of pay with NIM via the web wallet in case future situations tip the balance back in favour of that?

Answer:

Yes. I think the confusion here lies in seeing the wallet and nimiq pay as two worlds which are completely independent. The plan is to merge these two and keep both functionalities (keeping the best of both worlds) while having one single product. That would reduce cognitive load and make it easy for a user to start using it and not having to learn which one is the right choice for them: Wallet or Mobile app. And having staking and swaps on one but paying features on the other.

And you are spot on that this is our attempt to pivot into something that can realistically gain adoption in the short-medium term.

Feedback from user YodaFlame on Telegram

I agree the web should remain, in case if you lose/break your phone…

Answer:

Fully agree with this. The plan is not to remove web support. But actually add web support to Nimiq Pay and Mini Apps.

It’s great to see so much feedback in favor of keeping web native functionality. Thanks a lot for sharing your opinions.

Comment from User Transformist on Telegram (saved on Nimiq Pay for order)

Answer:

Thanks. Making them fully compatible is on the agenda. And it’s good that you are sharing this feedback regarding the ‘Back button’ and the recovery phrase compatibility. We will look into those points.